Course Syllabi ~ Spring Semester, 2001
Cleveland State University
UST 302 - CONTEMPORARY URBAN ISSUES (Section 1)
Version 11/00
Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs (UST 302 )
MEETING TIME: Monday, Wednesday, Friday 9:45-10:50 UR 102
Department of Urban Studies Spring Semester,
2001
Instructor: Prof. Dr. Harry L. Margulis
Office:Room 266, Chester Building
Phone: 216-687-2163
E-mail: h.margulis@popmail.csuohio.edu
Office hours: Monday, Wednesday, 1:00-2:00
and by appointment.
GENERAL EDUCATION REQUIREMENT:
This course fulfills the WRITING ACROSS THE CURRICULUM GenEd
university requirement. Students must earn a grade of C or better
in their concept paper writing assignment in order to apply UST
302 toward this requirement. This course also fulfills the AFRICAN
AMERICAN EXPERIENCE: RACE AND RACISM GenEd university requirement.
ATTENDANCE POLICY:
An attendance sheet shall be circulated precisely at 9:50 a.m.
Please make sure that you sign the sheet. Lateness or failure
to sign the attendance sheet shall count as an absence. You
may have three excused absences. For each absence thereafter students
shall lose five percent of the assigned attendance grade.
In brief, six absences shall result in the receipt of a zero
for the attendance grade.
Do not enter the classroom late. Late entry disturbs the continuity
of the lecture; it is disrespectful to the instructor and to students
who are conscientious. If students persist in arriving late, the
instructor shall lock the door precisely at 9:50 p.m.
EXAMINATION POLICY:
All take-home examinations must be submitted on the assigned
dates as indicated below. Failure to submit a midterm examination
on time shall result in a full grade reduction for each day the
examination is late. All examinations must be hand delivered in
hard copy to the instructor. Electronic delivery of examinations
(e-mail or zip file) is unacceptable. The midterm take-home examination
is due Wednesday, February 28, 2001. The final take-home
examination is due Wednesday, May 9, 2001 at 8:30 am.
The final examination shall be administered on the day and at
the time designated by the Administration in the CSU Fall 2000
Bulletin. See Article 11, 11.2 A(1), Page 14, Agreement,
CSU and American Association of University Professors, CSU Chapter,
Effective October 1, 1997).
- For all examination questions present the author(s) arguments;
do not argue you own position - personal feelings, or streams
of consciousness. Quotes from texts other than those used in the
class should be avoided. The instructor needs to know that you
have read and understood the required readings.
- In-class lectures and discussion examination answers (not covered
by the above paragraph) can be argumentative, informative, or
persuasive; they must contain supporting evidence (facts, statistics,
examples, or authoritative opinion). Use a structure that helps
you organize your answer(s), for example, arrange ideas by time,
importance, by problem and solution. Make sure you summarize the
main points in your conclusions. Avoid plagiarism; cite to sources
correctly and use quotation marks where appropriate. You may argue
you own position, but you must document the validity, correctness
or truthfulness of that position. Cite in-text references correctly
especially if they refer to non-class sources and be sure to include
an alphabetically listed reference section. Undocumented answers
with which the instructor disagrees shall lose points. In case
of conflict over an answer, the instructor wins. Make sure your
position is sustainable.
- Please write clearly. Indicate the part and number of the question
answered at the top of the first page of each essay. Use grammatically
correct, standard English. Questions are graded on the basis
of content and writing quality. Points shall be deducted for
errors of logic, grammar and syntax. Please word-process your
answers (double-space, 12 point font size). Handwritten
examinations shall not be accepted. You must write at least
three pages for each question. Try to avoid writing more than
three pages, but points shall not be deducted if you exceed the
three page requirement. Keep quotes to a minimum. Short quotes
should be imbedded in the text; longer quotes indented and single-spaced.
No quotations marks are needed for imbedded quotations.
- Each examination should have a cover page indicating your name,
the part(s) and question(s) answered. Staple the pages together
in the upper left-hand corner. Do not submit the examination in
a folder or binder.
COURSE DESCRIPTION:
A festering question consistently avoided by urban policy makers
is the divisiveness of race and what can be done to bring cohesiveness
to confrontational politics and society in general. Exploitation
and violence, as well as the politics of race are haunting America's
central cities. What has emerged are serious tensions between rights
and responsibilities in legal responses to crime, work place discrimination,
and residential segregation. Why are there persisting tensions between
the goals of social separation from whites and inclusion within
the broader society? Why are coalitions with other racial and ethnic
minorities so important for achieving legislative and administrative
changes? As West[1] notes, "Race is the most explosive issue in
American life precisely because it forces us to confront the tragic
facts of poverty and paranoia, despair and distrust. In short, a
candid examination of race matters takes us to the core of the crisis
of American democracy." Inevitably we must ask ourselves the pinnacle
question -- what kind of nation do we desire? -- one of equality
or injustice, one offering opportunity to all, or one in which opportunity
exists only for the few.
COURSE METHOD:
This course uses an interactive teaching approach consisting of
lectures, discussion, student presentation and debate methods.
WRITING ASSIGNMENT:
Each student shall be required to prepare a concept paper
based on a topic related to the course content.
- Several reference sources -- articles, books, chapters
in books, electronic journal articles, reports, internet sources
-- are to be used for each paper. Do not depend solely upon internet
sources. Quality research requires a variety of sources and balanced
perspectives.
- You shall need to read at least 250 or more pages to satisfactorily
write a high quality concept paper.
- Concept papers shall be no more than eight word-processed,
double-spaced pages (approximately 2000 - 2500 words; assume
250 words per page).
- You may attach appendices --bar graphs, line graphs, pie charts
and so forth. Whenever appendices are included, be sure that they
are clearly explained in the text, consecutively identified in
parentheses by Roman numerals or figure numbers, and that sources
are identified. The appendices should be labeled (i.e., Table
1: Socioeconomic Characteristics of Occupational Groups) and,
if separated from the paper, independently understood by a reader.
Sources for appendices must be indicated beneath the tables, charts
or graphs and the source must appear on the reference page.
- Include all references to books, articles, and other resource
materials on a separate reference page. References should
be alphabetically arranged by author as shown in the Urban
Affairs Review style sheet.
- All concept papers are to be written in standard English, spell-checked
and proof read for accuracy.
- On a separate page preceding your text, include a 150 word abstract
and a short biosketch, not to exceed 100 words (See examples
below). The title of the paper and student identification
should be included on the cover page. Number the pages in the
text consecutively. Refer to the Urban Affairs Review
style sheet (class handout) for the manuscript form required for
concept papers.
- Each concept paper must have a concise thesis statement that
is implicitly stated in the first paragraph. Identify and justify
any assumptions made, draw clear and obvious conclusions, and
be sure that your conclusions are justified by the evidence.
- Plagiarism may result in the student receiving a failing
grade for the piece of work involved.
- When citing to a secondary source in a book or article, use
the following form: (Van Dijk as cited by Campbell 1995, 27).
- All quotations must have appropriate attribution. All
in-text citations must appear on the reference page (See Urban
Affairs Review Manuscript Style Sheet 1999, 2d). References
should be alphabetically arranged in the style shown on pages
4 - 6.
- Online sources should be listed in the following manner on your
reference page (start with the author’s name): (Book) Landow,
G. 1997. Hypertex 2.0: The convergence of contemporary critical
theory and technology [Online]. URL http://www.stg.brown.edu/projects/hypertext/landow/ht/contents.html
(Article in an edited online work) Keegan, J. 1999. Normandy:
The invasion conceived, 1941-43. In Encyclopedia Britannica
[Online]. URL http://normandy,eb.com/normandy/week1/buildup.html
(World Wide Web document) Dice, R. 1998, June 15. Web Database
Crash course – Lesson 1 [WWW document]. URL http://www.hotwired.com/webmonkey/98/24/index0a.html?tw=frontdoor.
(Online newspaper) McDowell, R. 1999, April 12. Colorado students
struggle to understand rampage. The Boston Globe [Online
newspaper]. URL http://www.globe.com/news/daily/21/school.htm
(Online magazine article) Dubow, C. 1999, April 21. Turning
acorns into trees. Forbes [Online magazine]. URL http://www.forbes.com/tool/html/99/apr/0421/feat.htm.
- Handwritten papers shall not be accepted. Keep quotes to a
minimum. Do not string quotes together; paraphrase and cite correctly.
Quotations. Short quotations within the text should be indicated
by quotation marks; long quotations or extract material (without
quotation marks) should be indented about [1 ½ inches] along both
margins. Words, punctuation, or italicization not present in the
original should be enclosed in square brackets or noted as “ [italics
added]” (See Urban Affairs Review Manuscript Style Sheet 1999,
2c).
- The checklist found in the Urban Affairs Review
style sheet on pages 7 and 8 should be consulted. Also, use the
list below to evaluate your concept paper prior to submission.
- Materials - is the assignment carried out using
the appropriate up-to-date resources?
- Research Design - Organizational Structure -
Is there an introduction? Are the points which follow easily understood?
Are they supported with convincing examples? Does the conclusion
summarize the preceding material? Does it answer the question
or assignment?
- Style - Is the writing clear? Are the transitions
smooth? (allowing the reader to easily follow the argument?) Is
spelling a problem? grammar?
- Evaluation of content - Is the interpretation
understandable and convincing? Is the subject covered well?
- Conclusion - Is the essay adequately summarized
and brought to a conclusion? Is the paper creative and original?
Is the footnoting consistent in form? Is there a well documented
bibliography? Is there evidence of a strong research effort?
- The form of the abstract should be as follows:
RESALE HOUSING PRICES AND HOUSING MARKETS IN CLEVELAND,
OHIO’S SUBURBAN RINGS
ABSTRACT This study shows that in the suburban rings
surrounding Cleveland, Ohio average resale housing prices are
sustained through capitalization of quality-price preferences
for selective housing and community traits. In addition, average
resale housing prices are highest where local fiscal capacity
is built upon a strong residential-nonresidential tax base,
where the total valuation resulting is capitalized into housing
stock prices. High total valuation per pupil enables school
districts to maintain satisfactory expenditures per pupil that
contribute to the sustainability of resale housing prices. Nonetheless,
population growth in the peripheral, inner- and outer-edge suburban
rings is redirecting investment away from the contiguous ring
suburbs where the levying of a high effective millage is causing
total valuations per pupil to fall. Diminishing school district
quality and a shrinking tax base are harbingers of suburban
distress and housing disinvestment. [135 words].
BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH Dr. Harry Margulis is an associate
professor in the College of Urban Affairs and First College.
My research interests deal with housing, urban structure, and
urban processes. Recently published articles appear in the Urban
Affairs Review and Urban Studies. [39 words]
-
If you have any questions concerning manuscript style, please
consult Turabian, K.L. 1987. A Manual for Writers of Term
Papers, Theses, and Dissertations. Chicago: University
of Chicago Press, Fifth Edition.
- Concept papers are due: Monday, March 19, 2001.
Papers may be rewritten and resubmitted. Revised papers shall
be reevaluated and assigned a new grade by the instructor; previously
assigned grades shall be ignored. All rewritten concept paper
without exception are due: Fridaly, April 27, 2001. No
paper shall be accepted after the thirtheenth week of the term.
WRITING CENTER - SATELLITE OFFICE:
An easily accessible satellite operation of the Writing Center
is now open in the Levin College. Elizabeth Hays, a very experienced
writer tutor, is available every Wednesday from 3:00 to 6:00 to
provide assistance to students. Walk-ins are welcome. To insure
a time, make an appointment by calling the Office of Student Services
at 687-3884. Students are encouraged to use this valuable academic
support to enhance your written communication and (possibly) improve
your grades. Ms. Hayes is located in UR 245.
REQUIRED TEXTS:
Cose, E. 1993. The rage of a privileged class - Why are middle-class
blacks angry? Why should America care? New York: Harper-Collins
Publishers. Required (Cose)
Kellogg, W. 1996. African Americans in urban America - Contemporary
experiences. Dubuque, Iowa: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company.
-Recommended-Not Required (K)
Pattillo-McCoy, M. 1999. Black picket fences - Privilege
and peril among the black middle class. Chicago: The University
of Chicago Press. (P)
West, C. 1993. Race matters. New York: Vintage Books.
(W)
Woo, D. 2000. Glass ceilings and Asian Americans.
Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.
FINAL GRADES:
Final grades shall be determined on the following basis:
|
|
Percentage assigned
|
Points assigned
|
Letter Grade
|
|
Attendance
|
15
|
15
|
95% A
|
|
Midterm
|
30
|
50
|
90-94% A-
|
|
Final
|
30
|
50
|
87-89% B+
|
|
Concept Paper
|
25
|
50
|
84-86% B
|
|
Total
|
100%
|
165 Base
|
80-83% B-
|
| |
77-79% C+
|
|
74-76% C
|
|
70-73% C-
|
|
65-69% D+
|
|
60-64% D
|
|
Less than 60 F
|
RECOMMENDED READINGS SCHEDULE:
Jan 17 Introduction -- The organization of the course.
Jan 19 Introduction: Race Matters, 3-13 (West) Jan 22 Nihilism
in Black America, 17-31 (West)
Jan 24 The Pitfalls of Racial Reasoning, 35-49 (West) Jan 26 The
Crisis of Black Leadership, 53-70 (West)
Jan 29 Demystifying the New Black Conservatism, 73-90 (West)
Jan 31 Beyond Affirmative Action: Equality and Identity, 93-99
(West)
Feb 2 On Black-Jewish Relations, 103-116 (West)
Feb 5 Black Sexuality: The Taboo Subject, 119-131 (West)
Feb 7 Malcolm X and Black Rage, 135-151 (West)
Feb 9 Introduction: Shouts and Whispers, 1-10 (Cose)
Why Successful People Cry the Blues, Chapter 1: 11-26 (Cose)
Feb 12 Tiptoeing Around the Truth, Chapter 2: 27-52 (Cose)
Feb 14 A Dozen Demons, Chapter 3: 53-72 (Cose)
Feb 16 A Hostile and Welcoming Workplace, Chapter 4: 73-92 (Cose)
Feb 21 Crime, Class, and Clichés, Chapter 5: 93-110 (Cose)
Feb 23 Affirmative Action and the Dilemma of the “Qualified”, Chapter
6: 111-134 (Cose)
Young People, Old Ideas, Chapter 7: 135-152 (Cose)
Feb 26 White Racism, Black Racism, and the Search for Our Better
Selves, Chapter 8: 153-180 (Cose)
Feb 28 No More White Guilt, Chapter 9: (Cose)
Mid-term examination due
Mar 2 Chapter 1: The Black Middle Class: Who, When, and Where?
(P-M)
Mar 5 Chapter 2: The Making of Groveland (P-M)
Mar 7 Chapter 3: Generations through a Changing Economy (P-M)
Mar 9 Chapter 4: Neighborhood Networks and Crime (P-M)
Spring Break,Mar. 12-Mar. 18, 2001
Mar 19 Chapter 5: Growing Up in Groveland (P-M) Chapter 6: In a
Ghetto Trance (P-M)
Concept paper due
Mar 21 Chapter 7: Nike’s Reign (P-M)
Mar 23 Chapter 8: William “Spider” Waters, Jr.: Straddling Two
Worlds (P-M)
Last day to withdraw
Mar 26 Chapter 9: Typical Terri Jones (P-M)
Mar 28 Conclusions (P-M)
Mar 30 Introduction (Woo) Chapter 1: Inventing and Reinventing
“Model Minorities” (Woo)
Apr 2 Chapter 2: The State of Research on the Glass Ceiling
Apr 4 Chapter 3: A History of Virtual Segregation (Woo)
Apr 6 Chapter 4: The Educational Pipeline (Woo)
Apr 9 Chapter 5: The Glass Ceiling at “XYZ Aerospace” (Woo)
Apr 11 Chapter 6: The Bigger Picture (Woo)
Apr. 13,16,18,20,23 Instructor’s Lectures (See below) Apr 25 Student
presentations
Apr 27 Student presentations
Last day to submit rewritten concept paper
Apr 30 Student presentations
May 2 Student presentations
May 4 Student presentations
Last day of instruction
May 9 Final examination due
Instructor’s Lectures - Theoretical and Policy Issues:
(Source: Burman, S. 1995. The Black Progress Question - Explaining
the African American Predicament. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
The Inevitability of Antinomy These Things Take Time: The Liberal
Tradition and Black Progress Black Progress - America Right or Wrong:
The Neoconservative Response Everything and Nothing: Marxism, Capitalism,
and Black Progress Been Down So Long: Race, Culture, and Black Nationalism
Instructor’s Lectures - Unresolved Issues:
(Source: Cose, E. 1997. Color-Blind (Seeing Beyond Race in a Race
Obsessed World. New York: Harper-Collins Publishers.
Introduction - Trapped in the dominant dialogue Can a new race
surmount old prejudices? If destiny is not all in the genes, why
do we keep looking there? The limits of desegregation Should affirmative
action be kicked out of college? Does affirmative action have a
future? Looking into and behind the color-blind mind
Other lecture material sources:
Kellogg, W. 1996. African Americans in Urban America Contemporary
Experiences. Dubuque, Iowa: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company.
Chapter 8: Urban Crime
The Myth of Black Violence 224-227
Black Against Black Violence” and “Violence and Crime in the Black
Community 228-231 )
Crime, Youth Unemployment, and the Black Urban Underclass 232-240
Politics, Public Policy and Street Crime 241-250
Chapter 3: Work Force Participation and Equal Access
Black Women in the Workforce 72-79
Pressure Builds for Retreat on Affirmative Action 79-84
The War on Equal Opportunity 85-89
Class, Not Race 89-94
Ruling Rocks Foundation of Affirmative Action 95-99
Chapter 4: Community Economic Development
They Myth of Community Development 100-110
Black Initiative and Governmental Responsibility 110-115
Empowering Poor Neighborhoods 116-124
Chapter 5: Urban Education
From No Schools to Separate Schools to Desegregated Schools 126-136
Independent Neighborhood Schools: A Framework for the Education
of African Americans 137-143
Education and Cultural Diversity in the United States 144- 156
Chapter 6: Housing
All the Discomforts of Home: The Politics and Economics of Housing
158-173
The Black Flight to the “Burbs” 174-177
The Quiet Integration of Suburbia 178-179
Racially Diverse Communities: A National Necessity 180-201
EXAMINATION (25 points per question)
Answer two essay questions. One essay must be derived
from PART I, the other from PART II.
MIDTERM EXAMINATION
PART I (West)
1. Paranoia, homophobia, xenophobia, patriarchal power, and a
fear of cultural hybridity permeate African American society.
Discuss.
2. West acknowledges that black’s suffer ontological wounds and
emotional scars all of which leads to a deep seated anger, a boiling
sense of rage, and a passionate pessimism regarding America’s
will to justice. Discuss.
3. West criticizes Black leadership - academic and political
- questioning their motives, commitments, lack of vision, morality,
and their positions on significant issues. Discuss.
PART II (Cose)
1. Cose notes that race cannot be treated as a total irrelevancy
because the black middle-class confronts a reservoir of despair;
that regardless of status, political persuasion, or accomplishment
they are forced to bear an incredible burden of living a dual
life. Discuss.
2. Cose states that racism is not always just an illogical,
detached, and cruel attitude deriving from callous hate because
racism and hate have their genesis in fear. When fear is irrational
or unexamined, then racism must be held accountable. Discuss.
3. Corporate America, according to Cose, is playing a cruel trick
on African-Americans. A host of other factors, having nothing
to do with ability or merit, ultimately dictates how high one
can rise and those factors often differ as a function of race.
Discuss.
FINAL EXAMINATION
Answer two essay questions. One essay must be derived from
PART I, the other from PART II
. PART I .
1.Black middle-class neighborhoods are characterized by more
poverty, higher crime, worse schools, and fewer services than
white middle-class neighborhoods. How does this context influence
parents who are raising children, and adolescents and young adults
who are growing up in such a neighborhood?
2. What are the distinctive choices and transitions that black
middle-class youth experience? Why were some Gloveland youth following
a path to success, while others had concocted a recipe for certain
failure?
3. Discuss the ethnography of Groveland - linguistic style, code
switching, youth style and the importance of race for cultural
practices.
PART II
(Examinations questions should be available two
weeks before exam date.)
STUDENT DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Procedure:
Form groups of not less than four students. Spend ten to fifteen
minutes discussing the proposition. Refer to Cose’s book, The
rage of a privileged class for substantive arguments. Jot
down five major points that substantiate the argument. What do you
think about this argument?
1. Proposition: The black middle-class should be responsible
for the well-being of the black underclass and penalized for transgressions
of the black criminal class.
2. Proposition: Abolishing affirmative action would make black
intellectual capability easier to prove.
3. Proposition: The state of race relations is bad. The ‘next
generation’ for all its idealism, open-mindedness, and willingness
to embrace equality and racial integration, is not even close
to mastering the art of how to get along.
4. Proposition: Whatever conditions blacks find themselves in
is not the fault - or responsibility - of society at large, and
certainly not of whites, but is primarily attributable to the
inherent flaws of blacks and black society.
5. Proposition: People do not have to be racists - or have any
malicious intent - in order to make decisions that unfairly harm
members of another race.
6. Proposition: Industry no longer believes that race relations
is a problem worthy of attention. Why?
7. Proposition: Black middle-class status is provisional; there
is a permanent vulnerability suffered by African- American middle-class
professionals that exacts heavy emotional and psychological costs.
8. Proposition: The life chances of individual blacks has more
to do with their economic class position than with their day-to-day
encounters with whites.
9. Proposition: Blacks are not necessarily granted a presumption
of innocence, competence, or even complete humanity. Thus, racial
demons are allowed free reign as many Americans sow seeds that
can only yield bitter fruit.
10. Proposition: The rational response to black crime and violence
is estrangement, quarantining, and separation from that community.
11. Proposition: Stereotypes are an exaggeration but nonetheless
true depiction of an ethnic group. (As Cose notes, even many black
children raised in suburbia harbor fearful and terrible stereotypes
of inner-city blacks.)
STUDENT DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Procedure: Form groups of not less than four students. Spend
ten to fifteen minutes discussing the proposition. Refer to Pattillo-McCoy,
M. 1999. Black picket fences - Privilege and peril among the
black middle classfor substantive arguments. Jot down five
major points that substantiate the argument. What do you think about
the rational for these argument?
1. The problems confronting middle-class African Americans are
not solved by simply moving away from a low-income black family
and next door to a middle-class white family. The fact that a
neighborhood’s racial makeup is frequently a proxy for the things
that really count - quality of schools, security, appreciation
of property values, political clout, and availability of desirable
amenities - attests to the ways in which larger processes of discrimination
penalize blacks at the neighborhood level (Chapter 1).
2. It is evident in generations through a changing economy that
middle-class African Americans run a greater risk of downward
mobility than whites, who generally start off as more solidly
middle class in the first place (Chapter 3). Why have the generations
fared differently in Groveland? How do the generations interact
and support each other?
3. In Groveland, residential stability and the strong informal
ties that stability fosters do not completely prevent crime in
the neighborhood but instead, they work to circumscribe the criminal
activity that does exists by holding the neighborhood delinquents
interlocked within the bonds of familial and neighborhood associations;
networks of legitimate and deviant behavior that paradoxically,
and always precariously, keeps the peace (Chapter 4).
4. Growing up in Groveland means that there are simultaneously
privileges and constraints faced by the black middle class that
make the intermediate position of balancing street and decent
a common strategy for negotiating a variety of family situations
and local and community-wide settings (Chapter 5).
5. Groveland youth exist within a continuum of ghetto participation
where some youngsters exhibit the full package of gangsta styles
and behaviors, while at the opposite extreme are those who scoff
at the gangsta styles altogether. This continuum embodies three
analytical types: consumed, thrilled, and marginal. Discuss the
experiences, aesthetics, and repercussions of falling into a ghetto
trance (Chapter 6).
6. Many black youth grow up within a popular-culture that targets
them as consumers and inundates them with exciting images of the
gangsta lifestyle for which there are serious repercussions. Describe
how Nikes is indicative of the dialogue of symbols that matter
for courtship, for self-esteem, for aesthetic enjoyment, for gang
affiliation, and for distinction-making in Groveland (Chapter
7).
STUDENT DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
Procedure: Form groups of not less than four students.
Spend twenty to thirty minutes discussing the assigned statement
and where indicated the associated questions. Refer to Deborah Woo’s
book Glass ceilings and Asian Americans. Jot down several
major points upon which Pattilo-McCoy builds her argument(s). What
do you think about the rational for these argument?
(Questions to not yet written)
CHECKLIST EVALUATION OF CONCEPT PAPER
Student’s Name :
Final Concept Paper Score: /50
A. Materials - is the assignment carried out
using the appropriate up-to-date resources? Score: 5 Student
score:
B. Research Design - Organizational Structure
- Is there an introduction? Are the points which follow easily
understood? Are they supported with convincing examples? Does
the conclusion summarize the preceding material? Does it answer
the question or assignment?
Score: 10
Student score:
C. Style - Is the writing clear? Are the transitions
smooth? (allowing the reader to easily follow the argument?)
Is spelling a problem? grammar?
Score: 10
Student score:
D. Evaluation of content - Is the interpretation
understandable and convincing? Is subject covered well?
Score: 10
Student score:
E. Conclusion - Is the essay adequately summarized
and brought to a conclusion? Is the paper creative and original?
Score: 5
Student score:
F. In-text citations and reference page - Are
the in-text citations consistent in form? Are all in-text citations
listed on the reference page? Do the references follow the Urban
Affairs Review manuscript style sheet? Is there a well documented
reference page containing at least several references drawn
from different sources (i.e., journals, books, chapters in books,
documents, online sources)?
Score: 5
Student score:
G. Abstract - Does the abstract adequately summarize
the concept paper? Score: 5 Student score:
H. Biosketch - Does the biosketch adequately describe
the author?
Score: 5
Student score:
Remarks:
ELEMENTS OF A PRESENTATION
Student Name: ______________________________________________________________________
| Contents |
Excellent |
Good |
Satisfactory |
Fair |
Poor |
|
CONTENT - Time management; interesting; audience
used
|
|
|
|
|
|
| OPENER - What will be covered? Creativity - lead
into body |
|
|
|
|
|
| BODY - Logical order; complete |
|
|
|
|
|
| CLOSE - Recap main idea; restate importance of
talk; creativity |
|
|
|
|
|
| REFERENCE TO NOTES - eye contact; did not read
- glanced at outline occasionally; eye contact - left, right,
front |
|
|
|
|
|
| POISE ? stage presence; posture; relaxed; complete
control |
|
|
|
|
|
| VOICE - variety; rate; volume; sound |
|
|
|
|
|
| BODY LANGUAGE - Gestures; movement - gestures
not distracting |
|
|
|
|
|
| VOCABULARY - No slang; errors - pronunciation;
enunciation |
|
|
|
|
|
| IDEAS APPROPRIATE; DYNAMIC SPEAKER |
|
|
|
|
|
| A/V AIDS - Professionally prepared; helpful and
not distracting; easy to read and understand |
|
|
|
|
|
Comments:
|